In July, GameStop CEO Ryan Cohen dismissed the risk of disc-less games to the retailer’s business plan. He is now criticizing publishers for releasing games as digital downloads instead of physical discs.
Nintendeal put the two headlines side by side. The value of physical games to a retailer and their value to the person buying one can move in very different directions. GameStop can find other things to sell while a player loses the option to buy the version they wanted.
In a July 16 Bloomberg Tech interview, Cohen was asked how a move toward disc-less hardware and digital releases fit GameStop’s business plan. He said software accounted for less than 12% of the business, while collectibles made up more than half, and called the issue “totally, totally irrelevant.” That was a claim about GameStop’s exposure as it pursued a broader business centered on collectibles and a proposed eBay deal.
His newer comments, reported by Bloomberg on November 19, describe publishers’ shift to digital-only releases as a mistake. GTA VI offers a practical example of what those release decisions mean for buyers.
Rockstar’s official preorder information says boxed copies of GTA VI contain a download code and no disc. Some buyers have reported missing codes, leaving them with the packaging but without the means to activate their purchase.
A retailer can respond to falling software sales by finding other things to sell. Players face a narrower choice when the version they want to buy no longer exists. A redeemable code also works differently from a game disc that can be passed to another person after use. The contents of the box matter more than whether a shop has put that box on a shelf.
At launch, a shopper can walk into a game store, pay for GTA VI and leave carrying a box—with no disc to lend to a friend or sell when they are finished. A retailer’s software percentage offers that buyer very little comfort.
Image: Rockstar Games.





